|
|
|
MEMBERS: you have not been authenticated, log in at the top of the page. Tired of Logging-In? As you log-in edit your profile so the site remembers you!
The Use of Glucosamine, Chondroitin Sulfate, and Other Nutraceuticals in the Treatment of Arthritis of Horses
by Robert N. Oglesby DVM
Introduction
Introduction
»
Efficacy
»
Glucosamine & Chondroitin
»
Hyaluronate
»
MSM
»
ASU's
»
Dosages
»
A Few Last Words
»
More Info
Whether you call it chronic arthritis, osteoarthritis (OA) or degenerative joint disease (DJD), it is one of the most common causes of lameness problems in the horse or other equine...more. DJD is troubling because it is a progressive disorder and can become an exercise limiting lameness of the horse over time. For decades the mainstay of DJD treatment has been oral non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs like phenylbutazone and intra-articular steroid therapy and these are still some of the most useful treatments for keeping horses comfortable and working albeit often at a reduced work load...more.
Since the 1980's the benefits of various oral joint health nutraceuticals have been advertised for use in horses and equines with arthritis and have been advertised as a cure for arthritis in horses. These product's ingredients include:
- chondroitin sulfate (CS)
- glucosamine (GL)
- hyaluronic acid (HA)
- methylsulfonylmethane (MSM)
- avocado soybean unsaponifiables (ASU's)
While early studies seem to indicate a benefit from some of these products, legitimate questions remain. DJD is a difficult disease to study because of the normal waxing and waning nature of the disease. This is also a disease that has a high positive placebo effect. In experiments where placebos are also administered often a positive effect is noted, making the significance of the trial drug harder to evaluate. As a result the results of the research was in question and whether the medication was absorbed at all in a useful form caused many to ask, "is there a real benefit or not". Also of concern was the exact nature of the substance itself. These products were manufactured from a bewildering variety of natural substances including mussels, harvested cadaver cartilage, and cock's comb. These natural products are then chemically broken down to produce a large array of chemicals including various forms of chondroitin sulfates which include glucosamine and the polymer hyaluronate.
Ned Tijdschr Geneeskd. 2006 May 20;150(20):1105-7.
Effectiveness of dietary supplements in patients with osteoarthritis: the doubt persists
Lems WF, Bijlsma JW.; VU Medisch Centrum, afd Reumatologie 4A42, Amsterdam.
Earlier studies with glucosamines in patients with osteoarthritis have shown conflicting results. A placebo-controlled randomized trial was now carried out in 1583 patients with osteoarthritis. The primary endpoint was a 20% reduction in knee pain between baseline and week 24 according to the 'Western Ontario and McMaster Universities arthritis index'(WOMAC)-score. No statistically significant difference was found between the groups using placebo (60% response), glucosamine (64%), chondroitin sulphate (65%) or combination therapy (67%). The results of this trial do not support the hypothesis that glucosamines have a positive effect on symptoms in patients with osteoarthritis of the knee. However, (a) the chance of a statistically significant difference decreases with increasing magnitude of the placebo response, (b) there was a statistically significant reduction in the patients with moderate to severe pain, (c) when the pain was assessed with the more sensitive 'Outcome measures in rheumatology clinical trials (OMERACT) - Osteoarthritis Research Society International (OARSI)-score, there was a better response in the group given combined treatment, (d) the data on radiological progression and the effects on cartilage markers must still come in, and (e) the efficacy may have been higher if a different dietary supplement had been used. These questions on the design and the robustness of the study indicate that further studies are necessary.
|
Despite these questions a whole human and horse industry grew up around hundreds of different products with a number of different ingredients, each promising remarkable benefits. These products were not cheap. In spite of these questions and the cost, horse owners bought them and continue to use them today. It does seem that these products have the potential for improving joint health in horses but the optimal chemical composition including the relative proportions of ingredients, and proper dosages are still unanswered questions. This article discusses the current evidence on the use of these products, potential modes of action, and makes recommendations for the use of such products.
~Word Count: 2625 words (The average magazine page contains about 600 words);
~Last Updated: May 28, 2008;
How to Access this Article and Much More!
You have just read the introduction to one of our nearly 800 articles on horse care, diseases, and training. It includes a description of the contents of the unabridged version. As a guest you can access this article two different ways, either purchase the article or become a member and take advantage of all the benefits Horseadvice.com has to offer:
ARTICLE PURCHASE: for $7.00 USD you get instant access to the unabridged article. We guarantee your satisfaction or we will refund the purchase price:
JOIN HORSEADVICE: get instant access to this article and all we have to offer! Joining gives you 3 months access and the membership is renewed at this discounted rate. Review us for 7 days and if you are not satisfied, we will gladly refund your money and you may easily cancel at anytime.
Check out our Membership Drive Discount below but hurry this is only for a limited time and joining will never be cheaper! To get your discount on a Full Service or Full Access Membership use the following coupon code during check out:
Coupon code: MEMDRV
We use 128 bit SSL encryption, so your order is completely secure.
|
Your assurance of excellent customer service.
|
So that you know your online experience is safe.
|
Join Us at Horseadvice.com:
-
If you want accurate up-to-date information, 24 hours a day, reviewed by an equine veterinarian and horseman.
-
If you are tired of searching long lists of fluffy material that don‘t answer your questions.
-
If you want to discuss it now, with a experienced qualified expert and get input from over 3000 experienced horsemen.
|
Discussions on Glucosamine, Chondroitin Sulfate, and their use in Arthritis
|
Subtopics |
Posts |
Updated |
 | MSM not recommended? | 1 | 9 | Sep 7, 08 |
 | Glutamine, Corta-FLX, ulcers | 1 | 8 | Sep 30, 07 |
 | Powder VS Paste HA supplement | 1 | 8 | Sep 17, 07 |
 | Glucosamine amount | 1 | 6 | May 29, 07 |
 | Research Summary: Continued support for oral chondroprotective nutr... | 1 | 21 | Apr 13, 07 |
 | Updated Article | 1 | 1 | Mar 15, 07 |
 | Joint supplement Vetri-Science Labs product called Glyco-Flex plus. | 1 | 1 | Feb 9, 07 |
 | New Study on Oral Hyaluronan (HA) | 1 | 7 | Dec 27, 06 |
 | Cetyl M Joint Supplement | 1 | 7 | Jul 10, 06 |
 | Conquer gel | 1 | 6 | Jun 5, 06 |
 | Corta-Flx | 1 | 11 | Feb 24, 07 |
 | Levels of joint treatment | 1 | 2 | May 14, 06 |
 | Oral Hyalun (hyaluronic acid) | 1 | 33 | Jun 15, 06 |
 | Should I give glocosamine supplement - clicking noise at a jog/lope | 1 | 3 | Dec 1, 05 |
 | Duralactin | 1 | 5 | Jul 25, 05 |
 | More evidence for the use of oral joint supplements | 1 | 2 | Jul 21, 05 |
 | Temperature affects on MSM, Glucosamine, Condroitin | 1 | 9 | Aug 6, 05 |
 | Joint Supplements-CHOICES!! | 1 | 13 | May 7, 06 |
 | Experience with Hylaron? | 1 | 34 | Nov 23, 05 |
 | Glucosamine Dependency | 1 | 4 | Oct 14, 03 |
 | No more MSM or Flex-free??? | 1 | 9 | Aug 11, 03 |
 | Chondroitin sulfate vs glucosamine HCL, vs glucosamine sulfate | 1 | 77 | May 12, 03 |
 | Glucosamine and cosequin supplements for arthritis | 1 | 11 | Apr 21, 06 |
 | Supplements for arthritis and DJD | 1 | 2 | Mar 23, 06 |
 | Corta-FLX anyone? | 1 | 11 | Nov 4, 00 |
| Start a New Discussion
|
|